Good solid well-made bag; it has survived one trip already. It's quite big so could be tricky to manoeuvre in tight spaces (eg train leg of journey) but the various grab handles are really useful. It was bought to accommodate ski boots in one package - to deal with a lack of a third arm necessary when adding skis to the overall load! Plenty of room inside the different compartments but the starting weight handicap (which is all that cost the fifth star) means that there is a lot of air carried when constrained by budget airlines' weight limit. (Boots and bag accounted for well over half of that allowance before anything else was packed! Perhaps I need lighter boots?) Next test of the bag will be in March - with a more generous weight allowance.
Exactly the size we needed, seems durable but light. We will wait and see how it hold up to regular use by my son!